10/13/26
By: Jacob Daly
Most appellate litigators know that the odds of the Georgia Supreme Court granting a petition for a writ of certiorari are low, but just how low are they? A previous blog post analyzed the numbers for 2017-2020, and this post provides an inclusive update with the numbers for 2021-2025.
Between 2017 and 2025, 3,916 petitions were filed in the Georgia Supreme Court, 2,597 of which were filed in civil cases. See Figure 1. It granted only 327 (8.35%) of all petitions and only 230 (8.86%) of petitions in civil cases. See Figure 2. On average, 435 petitions were filed and 36 petitions were granted per year. In civil cases, an average of 289 petitions were filed per year, with the Court granting 26 per year. The annual numbers for these years are:
See Figures 1, 2, and 3.
Figures 4 and 5 illustrate the downward trend in both the percentage and number of petitions granted by the Court from 2017 until 2025. Overall, the Court granted 52 petitions in 2017, but by 2025 it granted only 18. The percentage of all petitions granted in 2017 was 10.08%, but in 2025 this percentage had dropped to 8/35%. In civil cases, the Court granted 35 petitions in 2017, which was 12.11% of the number filed, but only 14 in 2025, which was a mere 5.19%. Had the Court granted 12.11% of the petitions filed in civil cases in 2025, the number granted would have more than doubled to 33.
Knowing that the odds of a petition being granted are less than 10% is discouraging, but if you are one of the lucky few, your mood should improve when you consider the numbers regarding outcomes in cases decided on certiorari. In the 230 civil cases in which the Court granted a petition between 2017 and 2025, there were 13 different outcomes. See Figure 6.
If you represent the petitioner, your goal is to obtain a change to the ruling of the Court of Appeals. An outright reversal is the best possible outcome for the petitioner, and it has also been the most frequent outcome in civil cases, with the judgment in 86 of 230 cases (37.39%) being reversed or reversed in part. Other favorable outcomes for the petitioner were:
Combining all of these outcomes together yields an overall favorable outcome rate for the petitioner of 75.22% in civil cases (173 of 230 cases decided wholly or partially in favor of the petitioner).
On the other hand, the unfavorable outcomes for the petitioner are affirmed, which occurred in 37 of 230 cases (16.09%), and writ dismissed as improvidently granted, which occurred in 14 of 230 cases (6.09%), for an overall unfavorable outcome rate of 22.18%. The only other outcome is writ dismissed on motion, which occurred in 6 of 230 cases (2.61%). This outcome cannot be characterized as favorable or unfavorable for the petitioner because it likely means that the case settled while it was pending.
Determining whether to file a petition for a writ of certiorari in the Georgia Supreme Court is a difficult decision because it is fraught with uncertainty. Only the Justices know what motivates them to grant any particular petition, not to mention how they ultimately rule on the merits in any particular case. For appellate litigators, knowing the odds of a petition being granted and the odds of obtaining a favorable outcome thereafter is helpful for advising clients about whether to continue the fight after just having lost in the Court of Appeals. An analysis of the petitions decided by the Supreme Court between 2017 and 2025, as well as the outcomes in the cases in which the petition was granted, shows that there is a very low chance—less than 10% and perhaps as low as 5%—of your petition being granted, but if you can scale that initial obstacle, there is a very good chance—about 75%—of at least a partially favorable outcome for your client.
For more information, please contact Jake Daly at jacob.daly@fmglaw.com or your local FMG attorney.
Figure 1. Petitions for Writ of Certiorari Filed in the Georgia Supreme Court 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Figure 2. Petitions for Writ of Certiorari Granted by the Georgia Supreme Court 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Figure 3. Petitions for Writ of Certiorari in Civil Cases in the Georgia Supreme Court 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Figure 4. Percentage of Petitions for Writ of Certiorari Granted by the Georgia Supreme Court 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Figure 5. Number of Petitions for Writ of Certiorari Granted by the Georgia Supreme Court 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Figure 6. Petitions for Writ of Certiorari in the Georgia Supreme Court Outcome of Granted Petitions in Civil Cases 2017-2025

Source: Prepared by Jake Daly, FMG Law.
Share
Save Print