10/14/26
By: Michael Brown & Emily Mayfield
A recent decision from the Suffolk Superior Court’s Business Litigation Session in Boston provides an important reminder that carefully drafted website terms of use can play a critical role in defending against privacy-related litigation. In D’Antonio v. Tripadvisor, LLC, the court dismissed a putative class action brought under California’s Invasion of Privacy Act (“CIPA”), holding that the parties’ online agreement required application of Massachusetts law and precluded Anthony D’Antonio from relying on California’s more expansive privacy statute.
Anthony D’Antonio, a California resident, alleged that Tripadvisor unlawfully used a third-party tracking tool on its website that collected users’ IP addresses, device metadata, and other identifying information without consent. According to the complaint, the tracking technology was used to create consumer profiles that were shared or sold to third parties, allegedly in violation of CIPA. The lawsuit was originally filed in California, but the California court dismissed the action after enforcing a forum-selection clause contained in Tripadvisor’s Terms of Use requiring disputes to be brought in Massachusetts. D’Antonio subsequently refiled the case in Suffolk Superior Court.
Once in Massachusetts, Tripadvisor moved to dismiss the complaint based on a separate provision in its Terms of Use requiring that Massachusetts law govern any disputes arising from use of the website. Judge Christopher K. Barry-Smith agreed, concluding that D’Antonio was bound by the choice-of-law clause and therefore could not rely on California law to state a claim. The court reasoned that the California court’s prior enforcement of the forum-selection clause effectively resolved the same contract-formation issues underlying the choice-of-law provision. Moreover, applying Massachusetts law independently led to the same conclusion because Tripadvisor provided reasonable notice of its Terms of Use and D’Antonio manifested assent by completing the account registration process.
In reaching its decision, the court relied on Massachusetts principles governing online contract formation, including the Supreme Judicial Court’s decision in Good v. Uber Technologies, Inc. While the court observed that Tripadvisor could have made its terms more conspicuous through larger font, greater contrast, or placement elsewhere on the page, it emphasized that the relevant inquiry is not whether a website employs the ideal registration interface. Rather, the question is whether a reasonably prudent user received sufficient notice of the terms and reasonably manifested assent to them. Under the totality of the circumstances, the court found that Tripadvisor satisfied those requirements.
For businesses operating customer-facing websites, D’Antonio underscores the importance of reviewing online contracting practices. Companies should ensure that users receive clear notice of website terms, that forum-selection and choice-of-law provisions are prominently disclosed, and that user assent is adequately documented. Although Tripadvisor ultimately prevailed, the court’s repeated observation that the company’s disclosures could have been more prominent serves as a warning that businesses should not treat website terms as mere boilerplate. Well-designed clickwrap agreements may reduce litigation risk and provide a powerful tool for defending against privacy claims brought under unfavorable state laws.
For more information, please contact Michael Brown at michael.brown@fmglaw.com and Emily Mayfield at emily.mayfield@fmglaw.com or your local FMG Law attorney.
Information conveyed herein should not be construed as legal advice or represent any specific or binding policy or procedure of any organization. Information provided is for educational purposes only. These materials are written in a general format and not intended to be advice applicable to any specific circumstance. Legal opinions may vary when based on subtle factual distinctions. All rights reserved. No part of this presentation may be reproduced, published or posted without the written permission of Freeman Mathis & Gary, LLP.
Share
Save Print