Overview

Patrick J. Thomas is a Partner in the Cleveland office of Freeman Mathis & Gary, LLP. Mr. Thomas is a member of the Commercial Litigation, Professional Liability/Errors & Omissions, and the Tort & Catastrophic Loss practice sections and is part of the Firm’s Intellectual Property and Lawyers Professional Liability interdisciplinary teams. Mr. Thomas focuses his practice on complex litigation, including business and commercial disputes, construction defect claims, environmental litigation, and intellectual property disputes involving unfair competition, trademark, and copyright infringement, as well as legal malpractice litigation. He has successfully defended clients in significant matters involving municipal infrastructure failures, large-scale construction defect claims, environmental contamination and EPA-related actions, high-value business and investment disputes, and federal intellectual property litigation. Mr. Thomas also represents clients in trademark cancellation and opposition proceedings before the United States Trademark Trial and Appeal Board. Mr. Thomas is a licensed patent attorney.

Mr. Thomas has substantial experience handling legal malpractice matters arising from a variety of professional liability scenarios. His experience includes matters involving alleged failures to analyze and secure available insurance coverage in underlying litigation, deficiencies in trial preparation and litigation strategy, conflicts of interest arising from dual representation, and fee-related disputes in which legal malpractice claims were asserted defensively. These matters have involved complex issues of causation, damages, professional responsibility, and insurance coverage, and have included claims against attorneys and related third parties.

Mr. Thomas has represented a diverse range of clients, including insurance companies, Fortune 500 corporations, small and mid-sized businesses, and individuals across a variety of industries, including construction, manufacturing, and commercial enterprises. He regularly advises clients and in-house counsel on risk assessment, litigation strategy, and dispute resolution. Mr. Thomas has represented clients in many jurisdictions, including Ohio, New York, Illinois, Georgia, California, and before the United States Patent and Trademark Office.

Mr. Thomas has earned his J.D. from Case Western Reserve University School of Law and his Bachelor of Science in Biology from Denison University. Prior to entering private practice, he served as an Assistant Prosecuting Attorney in the Major Trial Division of the Cuyahoga County Prosecutor’s Office, where he acted as first chair in more than 90 jury trials involving serious felony offenses, including homicides and sex crimes. Earlier in his career, Mr. Thomas worked as a research scientist at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, where he designed, cloned, and expressed a recombinant human nervous system enzyme for purposes of assessing enzyme kinetics. His scientific training and attention to detail continue to inform his approach to complex litigation.

Read more

Bar Admissions

Ohio

Education

J.D.

Case Western Reserve University School of Law

B.S.

Denison University

Representative Cases & Clients

  • Successfully defended a subcontractor in litigation arising from the HUD‑funded restoration and conversion of a large residential complex into condominiums, involving alleged construction defects that resulted in significant water intrusion claims.
  • Obtained a favorable defense and definitive settlement on behalf of an insured, effectively shielding the client from future regulatory exposure stemming from a major trichloroethylene (TCE) release at a large industrial facility and eliminating potential EPA enforcement liability.
  • Successfully prosecuted a cost‑recovery action under 42 U.S.C. § 9607 (CERCLA) against the United States, including EPA Region 5, in response to a Unilateral Administrative Order, on behalf of an employer whose environmental remediation credentials were fraudulently misappropriated by a former employee and third parties.
  • Successfully defended an employer against claims by a former officer alleging equity ownership and partnership rights in contravention of governing agreements, including obtaining employer‑favorable rulings before the California Department of Industrial Relations.
  • Secured a key federal court ruling granting defendants’ motion for a temporary restraining order, preventing termination of a critical warehouse storage agreement during the pendency of complex litigation and effectively dismantling the plaintiff’s claims at an early stage.
  • Resolved federal unfair competition, false advertising, and trademark infringement claims through a nuisance‑value settlement on behalf of defendants, avoiding exposure to nearly $1 million in alleged damages.
  • Successfully defended a candle manufacturing company against copyright infringement claims involving religious-themed candles, including eliminating any exposure to statutory damages despite allegations of clear infringement.

Affiliations

Ohio State Bar Association, 2003-Present

Education

J.D.

Case Western Reserve University School of Law

B.S.

Denison University

FMG Law Firm Services for Insureds – Emergency Legal Support Blogline