Trial Wins

David Molinari Receives Favorable Verdict in North County San Diego Superior Court

David Molinari obtained a favorable judgment on behalf of our Client, a homeowner’s association, after a five day jury trial in North County San Diego Superior Court. This case involved a claim of continuing nuisance,…

Download Now

David Molinari obtained a favorable judgment on behalf of our Client, a homeowner’s association, after a five day jury trial in North County San Diego Superior Court. This case involved a claim of continuing nuisance, involving water irrigation pumps located on our Client’s property. The Plaintiff, a neighboring landowner, claimed the pumps caused extreme noise while in operation and caused a loss of use relating to areas of his home. The Plaintiff sought damages and an injunction against our client’s use of the pumps. Both sides retained audio sound engineers that measured decibel readings when the pumps were in operation and recorded the ambient noise at the plaintiff’s property line when the pumps were in operation. Only the defense expert’s sound recording went to the jury, Plaintiff voluntarily did not introduce his recordings into evidence and Plaintiff’s expert did not submit their recordings or rely on the recordings to render opinions on Plaintiff’s behalf. The jury was instructed on what level of annoyance constitutes a nuisance under a “reasonable person standard.” Focusing on that standard, Mr. Molinari argued to the jury that they may use their own senses of sight and sound to see the location of the pumps, see the distance between the pumps and Plaintiff’s property and hear for themselves what, if any noise, was produced by the pumps and make a determination on the claim. The jury concluded a reasonable person would not have been annoyed and returned a defense verdict. The defense verdict allowed for the recovery of litigation costs incurred by our Client. This case went through our standard FMG roundtable process, conducted by our Trial Committee, which further supported this trial win and assisted in keeping the defense fees minimal.

Professionals

More Successes

Defense Verdict In Jury Trial in Georgia Superior Court

FMG Attorneys Marc Bardack and Wes Jackson obtained a defense verdict for client homeowners sued by their downhill neighbors for allegedly creating and maintaining a continuing nuisance and trespass due to excess surface water runoff…

Chad Weaver and Elizabeth Lowery Obtain Favorable Result in FINRA Arbitration

FMG attorneys, Chad Weaver and Elizabeth Lowery, obtained a favorable result for a prominent life insurance company after a three week FINRA arbitration. The matter involved a FINRA claim filed by two registered representative claimants…

Lizel Cerezo Obtains Defense Verdict in the Superior Court of California for San Bernardino

Lizel Cerezo obtained a defense verdict in the Superior Court of California for San Bernardino for a commercial trucking client.  The case involved a tractor-trailer vs. motor home rear-end collision on the I-15 Baker Grade. The…

Casey Stansbury, Curt Graham and Austin Anderson Receive Favorable Verdict

Casey Stansbury, Curt Graham and Austin Anderson tried a civil case before a 12-person jury in Laurel Circuit Court (Kentucky). The case arose from an automobile accident on I-75 in Laurel County. We defended Laurel…

Paul Bigley and Matthew Jones Win Big in Alhambra, California Trial

Congratulations to Paul Bigley and Matthew Jones, who received a defense verdict after a three-week trial in Alhambra, California. This action was ongoing for almost three years. This was a wrongful death action that arose…