Appellate Advocacy

At the appellate stage of a complex litigation matter, a special set of skills and knowledge is needed to successfully obtain appellate relief.

Download PDF

Reach & Depth

Appellate litigation carries high stakes because it is a zero-sum game. In most instances, the process begins with one side already declared the winner. Perhaps the trial court has dismissed a plaintiff’s complaint or entered judgment on a significant jury verdict in the plaintiff’s favor. Or perhaps the client achieved a defense verdict in a high-stakes trial that the plaintiff intends to aggressively attack. In each case, one side seeks to fight another day by convincing an appellate court that the trial judge erred in applying the law, while the other defends the status quo.

Appellate advocacy differs from trial advocacy in its focus on applying the law to the evidentiary record under the applicable standard of review. In many instances, that requires seeking a clarification or change to existing law. Persuasive legal writing and oral advocacy are paramount to meeting that challenge.

FMG Law puts appellate practice on equal footing with trial. We recognize the unique skill set required to protect our clients’ interests both before and when their cases reach the appellate courts. Far from an afterthought, our understanding of appellate procedure underlies our resolution strategy, and our clients value the perspective our experienced practitioners bring to every stage in the arc of the case.

Our seasoned team of appellate lawyers understands how to effectively advocate for our clients in state and federal appellate courts throughout the country, as well as the Supreme Court of the United States. We bring experience and expertise across a broad range of substantive areas, including torts, government, state and federal constitutional issues, employment, insurance coverage, commercial disputes, construction, financial services, and healthcare.

Significant Appellate Matters

Click the categories below to view notable matters handled by FMG Law’s appellate attorneys.

Successes

FMG Law secured a reversal in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on behalf of a police chief, with the court holding that the chief was entitled to qualified immunity from multiple claims asserted under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The Sixth Circuit held that no constitutional violation occurred and rejected the plaintiff’s challenges to the stop, inventory search, and arrest, emphasizing that qualified immunity cannot be defeated merely by identifying factual disputes and that the Fourth Amendment does not require perfect compliance with every departmental procedure.

This decision reinforces important protections for law enforcement officers and municipalities, including the principle that the reasonableness of police conduct must be evaluated in light of practical realities rather than through the lens of hindsight. The court’s opinion provides valuable guidance regarding probable cause, inventory-search procedures, and the proper role of qualified immunity in civil-rights litigation.

See More

Professionals

Team Leadership

Click to see our team

Related News & Blogs

    • Rated by

      Super Lawyers Business Law

    • Recognized by

      Best Lawyers

    • Benchmark Litigation

      Star Litigator

FMG Law Firm Services for Insureds – Emergency Legal Support Blogline