Reach & Depth
Appellate litigation carries high stakes because it is a zero-sum game. In most instances, the process begins with one side already declared the winner. Perhaps the trial court has dismissed a plaintiff’s complaint or entered judgment on a significant jury verdict in the plaintiff’s favor. Or perhaps the client achieved a defense verdict in a high-stakes trial that the plaintiff intends to aggressively attack. In each case, one side seeks to fight another day by convincing an appellate court that the trial judge erred in applying the law, while the other defends the status quo.
Appellate advocacy differs from trial advocacy in its focus on applying the law to the evidentiary record under the applicable standard of review. In many instances, that requires seeking a clarification or change to existing law. Persuasive legal writing and oral advocacy are paramount to meeting that challenge.
FMG Law puts appellate practice on equal footing with trial. We recognize the unique skill set required to protect our clients’ interests both before and when their cases reach the appellate courts. Far from an afterthought, our understanding of appellate procedure underlies our resolution strategy, and our clients value the perspective our experienced practitioners bring to every stage in the arc of the case.
Our seasoned team of appellate lawyers understands how to effectively advocate for our clients in state and federal appellate courts throughout the country, as well as the Supreme Court of the United States. We bring experience and expertise across a broad range of substantive areas, including torts, government, state and federal constitutional issues, employment, insurance coverage, commercial disputes, construction, financial services, and healthcare.
Significant Appellate Matters
Click the categories below to view notable matters handled by FMG Law’s appellate attorneys.
Successes
FMG Law secured a reversal in the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit on behalf of a police chief, with the court holding that the chief was entitled to qualified immunity from multiple claims asserted under 42 U.S.C. § 1983. The Sixth Circuit held that no constitutional violation occurred and rejected the plaintiff’s challenges to the stop, inventory search, and arrest, emphasizing that qualified immunity cannot be defeated merely by identifying factual disputes and that the Fourth Amendment does not require perfect compliance with every departmental procedure.
This decision reinforces important protections for law enforcement officers and municipalities, including the principle that the reasonableness of police conduct must be evaluated in light of practical realities rather than through the lens of hindsight. The court’s opinion provides valuable guidance regarding probable cause, inventory-search procedures, and the proper role of qualified immunity in civil-rights litigation.
Two companion Colorado Court of Appeals decisions delivered appellate wins for FMG’s insurance broker clients, affirming summary judgment and reinforcing key limits on broker liability.
In Mayfield v. DeLaCroix, the Court held that an agent owes no duty for a later-renewed policy she neither placed nor serviced, rejected negligent misrepresentation claims where policy language contradicted alleged oral assurances, and declined to find any fiduciary or “special relationship” based on routine agent conduct.
In Wyss v. Campbell, the Court reaffirmed that agents owe a duty of reasonable care—not an obligation to recommend higher limits or ensure complete protection—and rejected attempts to impose heightened duties. The Court also upheld judgment for the insurer on reformation and bad faith claims.
Together, these decisions provide strong, practical authority limiting expanded theories of broker and agent liability in Colorado.
Mayfield v. DeLaCroix, Colorado Court of Appeals Case no. 24CA2026; Wyss v. Campbell, Colorado Court of Appeals Case nos. 24CA1352 & 24CA1845
FMG Law attorney Elissa Haynes secured an appellate victory in the Georgia Court of Appeals, which unanimously affirmed summary judgment in a wrongful death action arising from a fatal fall at an electrical battery plant. The Court held that the decedent, an experienced electrical foreman who fell while working above the ceiling without using the proper safety equipment, had actual knowledge of the specific hazard posed and voluntarily exposed himself to that risk by failing to use the safety equipment, despite repeated training, written safety policies, a job safety analysis identifying the hazard, and contemporaneous warnings from co‑workers. The Court rejected arguments that alleged changed site conditions or reassurances created a jury issue, emphasizing that a worker’s misjudgment does not negate prior actual knowledge of a known hazard.
Daniella Mejia v. BrandSafway Solutions, LLC et al.; Georgia Court of Appeals; Case No. A25A2164
FMG Law attorney Will Covino prevailed in the Massachusetts Appeals Court on behalf of a local accounting firm, defeating an accounting‑malpractice claim in which the plaintiffs sought millions of dollars in damages tied to purported below‑market valuations and allegedly fraudulent gift‑tax returns used to transfer securities. The Superior Court dismissed all claims against the accounting firm, which the Appeals Court affirmed, delivering a complete appellate win for the client.
Mark Kinchla, et al. v. Hildred Pennoyer, Michael Kinchla, and O’Connor & Drew, P.C.
In a collaboration among FMG Law’s Labor & Employment, Government Law, and Appellate Advocacy practice groups, attorneys Jack Hancock and Michael Freed obtained a reversal of a federal district court’s ruling denying qualified immunity to a county commissioner. That commissioner, along with two others, voted to terminate the employment contract of the county’s chief financial officer. She sued the county and the three commissioners claiming she was terminated in retaliation for her husband’s political activities in violation of her First Amendment right to intimate association. FMG Law argued that its client was entitled to qualified immunity because the plaintiff failed to allege a violation of clearly established law. The district court denied this argument, but after appeal, Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals agreed with FMG, reversed the district court’s order, and ordered that the commissioner should be dismissed from the case.
Bivins v. Hambrick et al.; United States Court of Appeals for the Eleventh Circuit; Case No. 23-13029
FMG Law attorneys Scott Anderson, Jacob Madsen and Cameron Regnery recently obtained a victory in the Court of Appeals of Georgia, receiving a judgment affirming dismissal of all claims against a Georgia insurance broker. The plaintiff, a commercial trucking company, alleged that the insurance broker caused its denial of insurance coverage. Asserting claims for breach of fiduciary duty and negligence, the plaintiff sought over $200,000 in damages. The trial court dismissed the case, holding that the insurance broker did not cause the denial of coverage. The Court of Appeals agreed and affirmed the dismissal of all claims.
Atarod Trucking Company, LLC v. Renegade Insurance LLC, Court of Appeals of Georgia, Case No. A25A1457
FMG Law attorneys Sun Choy and Wes Jackson prevailed on all claims in a wrongful death civil rights action on behalf of four deputies at a metro-area county jail. The plaintiffs claimed the four deputies failed to provide adequate medical care to their father and brother, who died in the jail from a perforated ulcer. However, the deputies had relied on the advice of contract medical professionals at the jail. The plaintiffs sought $50 million in a pre-suit demand. The trial court granted summary judgment to the officers on all counts. On appeal, the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, in a unanimous, published decision, held as a matter of law that a nonmedical jail officer cannot be found liable for deliberate indifference when the officer reasonably relies on the advice or opinion of a medical professional, and because the deputies in this case reasonably relied on the nurses’ diagnosis, they were not deliberately indifferent.
Tiffany Wingo et al. v. Major Branson Harris et al., Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, No. 24-10933.
FMG Law attorneys Phil Savrin and Bill Buechner secured summary judgment in favor of an insurance company that had been sued for millions of dollars in claimed property losses. The lawsuit was filed in 2019 and took several years to make its way through the federal courts, including a trial on two claims that resulted in a defense verdict on the question of bad faith and the dismissal of the remaining claims by the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals.
Transworld Foods v. Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company, Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals, Case No. 24-11121, Federal Court – Northern District of Georgia and Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals
FMG Law attorneys Dana Maine and Kevin Stone obtained a win in the Georgia Court of Appeals in a tort and breach of contract case against a governmental entity and its development authority. The plaintiff, a subsidiary of a national real estate management corporation, sought over $1.4 million in damages. The Court of Appeals agreed with FMG Law and held the plaintiff’s tort claims were barred by sovereign immunity and the plaintiff failed to state a claim for nuisance, inverse condemnation, or breach of contract.
DeThomas Investments, LLC v. LMRK PropCo, LLC, A25A0848, 2025 WL 1923873 (Ga. App. July 14, 2025)
Sophie Stevanovich obtained a favorable decision from the Illinois Appellate Court affirming the use of exculpatory clauses. Plaintiff broke her ankle after falling while top rope climbing at an indoor facility. Plaintiff argued the exculpatory agreement she had signed should be voided because it was prohibited by Illinois’ Amusement Ride and Attraction Safety Act (the “Act”), which requires facilities licensed under the Act to have $1 million in liability insurance. Brad Purcell obtained summary judgment in favor of FMG Law’s client in the trial court. FMG attorneys Michael Sanders and Sophie Stevanovic defended our client on appeal and convinced the appellate court to reject each of the Plaintiff’s arguments. In a case of first impression, the appellate court found that the Act does not prohibit exculpatory clauses.
Amy Taylor v. Brooklyn Boulders LLC, and Chicago Climbing Gym Company, LLC; Case No.: 2025 IL App (1st) 231912
Cara Wright received an affirmed summary judgment in Ohio’s Third District Court of Appeals in favor of FMG Law’s client, a local school district board of education, in a slip and fall case. Plaintiff alleged that the school district was negligent in electing not to use a removable step at the end of the bleachers, resulting in the last step between the bleachers and the gym floor to be about twice as high as the rise between the other steps. The appellate court affirmed that the difference in riser height was open and obvious and rejected plaintiff’s argument that other circumstances (a trash can placed on the floor near the stairs and the basketball players warming up) distracted the plaintiff and negated the open and obvious nature of the condition.
Bradshaw v. North Union Local School District Board of Education
Will Covino prevailed in obtaining the dismissal of a myriad of legal malpractice and conspiracy-based claims asserted against an attorney who purportedly facilitated an oral loan agreement designed to defraud judgment creditors. The Middlesex Superior Court agreed the Amended Verified Complaint and a proposed Second Amended Complaint failed to plausibly suggest an entitlement to relief against the attorney. The plaintiff filed an appeal. A single justice of the Appeals Court agreed the plaintiff had failed to establish a clear error of law or abuse of discretion in this dismissal.
Edward P. O’Neil, III, et al. v. Estate of Charles E. Gaudet, et al., Middlesex Superior Court, C.A. No. 2281-CV-03571.
Bob Chadwick prevailed on appeal in the Sixth Appellate District of Texas before three state judges. In this matter a plaintiff sued his former attorney for legal malpractice. The petition was dismissed on a 91(a) Motion to Dismiss. Plaintiff filed a notice of appeal arguing that he never received proper notice of the 91(a) hearing despite being served through the electronic filing manager. Plaintiff raised this issue for the first time on appeal. On behalf of the clients, FMG Law’s attorney argued that plaintiff waived his rights to appeal by not preserving the issue at the trial court. The Court of Appeals agreed with the Appellees that the issue had not been preserved. Therefore, the Court did not have to rule on the issue of notice and affirmed the trial court’s dismissal.
CARL RALPH DAILY v. PHIL SMITH AND LAW OFFICE OF PHIL SMITH. Sixth Appellate District of Texas at Texarkana
Barry Miller from FMG Law’s Lexington, Kentucky office prevailed in a matter before the Kentucky Court of Appeals where the plaintiff challenged the enforcement of a settlement agreement that purportedly resolved a claim against our client. After conclusion of the underlying case, the plaintiff sought to sue parties previously identified only as “John Does.” Ultimately, the Court of Appeals found the language of the settlement agreement was sufficiently broad in scope and that our client had bargained for complete relief from all claims, known or unknown. The opinion puts the burden on the releasing party to negotiate and carve out any exceptions to broad settlement language.
Vale Rive Development LLC v. Estate of Kenneth Ankrom, Court of Appeals of Kentucky, Civil Action No. 2022-CA-0898-MR.
Michael Freed prevailed in an appeal before the Georgia Supreme Court by an insured apartment owner/manager. FMG Law’s client issued an umbrella policy to the insured which “followed form” to a primary policy which contained a firearms exclusion. The carrier sent the insured a reservation of rights letter and later sent supplemental letters which clarified the reservation of rights.
The litigation arose following an action seeking a declaration that the carrier had no duty to defend the insured in the underlying shooting claim, and our client prevailed at summary judgment. In an October 2022 opinion, the Georgia Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court and found that the carrier’s initial reservation of rights was sufficient to preserve coverage defenses. Hernandez v. Great Am. All. Ins. Co., 365 Ga. App. 511, 879 S.E.2d 522 (2022). The insured requested review by the Georgia Supreme Court, which denied the request. This case was also handled by Mike Athans who has retired from the firm.
Star Residential, LLC et al. v. Great American Alliance Insurance Company, Georgia Supreme Court, Case Number S23C0255.
Michael Freed and Matt Boyer prevailed in the Eleventh Circuit Court of Appeals in an insurance coverage case addressing the priority of coverage between its client’s umbrella policy and another carrier’s underlying primary policy. The case arose from a shooting on the insured’s premises. The other carrier asserted that the “excess clause” in its primary policy was excess to FMG Law’s client’s umbrella policy. The district court disagreed and granted summary judgment in favor of our client. Relying on precedent from the Georgia Supreme Court, the Eleventh Circuit affirmed.
Marc Shrake and Christian Nagy were handed a win for the City of Page, Arizona following an appeal from a successful motion for summary judgment. A tourist taking photographs in a parking lot owned by the City of Page was struck and killed by a tour bus. After being sued by the tourist’s family, the bus owner filed a cross-complaint against the City on the theory that it had failed to maintain the parking lot it set up for tourists to visit Horseshoe Bend on the Colorado River.
The Court of Appeals affirmed summary judgment in the City’s favor, agreeing with our statutory interpretation of “premises” and holding that the bus owner had failed to introduce any admissible evidence of gross negligence by the City (which would have overcome the statutory qualified immunity). In so doing, the Court also shot down appellants’ argument that objections not ruled on at the summary judgement stage were waived, expressly finding that we had preserved the City’s objections and sustaining a critical hearsay objection against the bus owner. The City was awarded its costs on appeal.
Edward Storck obtained summary judgment in a case involving suit by plaintiff against the client dealership and the tortfeasor who was loaned a motor vehicle by the client dealership while the tortfeasor’s vehicle was in for repairs. Tortfeasor struck plaintiff while he was riding his motorcycle causing significant injuries with damages well in excess of the policy for the tortfeasor. Plaintiff brought suit against the dealership pursuant to Conn. Gen. Stat. § 14-154a which created vicarious liability for motor vehicle lessors. In the underlying suit, FMG Law successfully obtained Summary Judgment on behalf of the dealership pursuant to Conn. Gen. Stat. § 14-60, which grants immunity for dealers who loan motor vehicles/dealer plates to customers while the customer’s vehicle is being prepared and the dealership obtains proof of insurance from the customer. In the Appeal, Plaintiff argued that the trial court got it wrong by concluding that there was no question of fact that the transaction was a loan and not a rental. The Appellant argued that the agreement that the Dealership had the customer signed used the word rental approximately 27 times throughout the document, the document itself was titled “Rental Agreement” and the agreement itself indicated that it was for consideration. The Plaintiff argued that a jury should have been allowed to decided what type of transaction was involved.
See MoreLess